Wednesday, September 02, 2020

Book Review Club - September 2020

To be honest, I'm not 100% certain where I heard about this book.  I'm assuming it was because Good Morning America made it its book of the month recommendation for June.  But whatever it was, I was lucky because I got the ebook from my library quickly (I looked at the "backlog" as I was reading - in early July - and there were 140 people waiting to read the book!).

First let me say, I loved this book!  I'd heard it described as two sisters, one deciding to live as a white woman, the other living as a black woman.  A lot of questions came to mind, why?  How? Among others.  I was curious.

The story covers time from the 1950s until around 1990 and starts in a small town in Louisiana called Mallard.  Mallard is so small, it doesn't even make it onto any map and no one outside of Mallard has ever heard of it.  The sisters who live the "advertised" lives of a black woman and a white woman come from the family that founded Mallard.  It was their great, great, great, great grandfather (give or take a few "greats") that founded the town.  With each generation born, their skin tone gets lighter and that appears to be the goal.  But, even though by the time the sisters (Stella and Desiree) are born they are light enough they could pass for white, they're still known to be black in Mallard and the lines are clearly drawn.

The young sisters watch as white men, who feel their father has cheated them, storm their house, drag their father out of the house by his ankles, beat him and shoot him.  Then when their father somehow  survives that, the men go to the hospital to finish the job of killing him.  How each sister processes that life event determines how they live their life going forward.

I don't want to give too much away but I will say the characters were very complex and interesting. Multi-generational viewpoints were explored and examined.  The "what happens next" wasn't obvious or expected and even addressed the changing times during the 60s and 70s in particular.  I didn't want to put the book down. 

Given the events occurring in this country as I write this (July 9th), it highlights that despite how far we think we've come when it comes to race relations, it shows just how little things have changed for black Americans today.  And sadly it seems like we've been going in the wrong direction in that regard.

Despite that, my recommendation would be the same - I highly recommend it.  Well written, great story, complex characters.  It really covers the full spectrum of life.  It's a great book.

For more great book reviews go to https://barriesummy.blogspot.com/index.html.

6 comments:

Barrie said...

Based on your glowing recommendation, I'm adding to my TBR pile. Who knows how long the list is at my library. :) Anyway, this sounds like a solid read. And I think you're right; we've haven't come as far with race relations as we'd thought. :( Oh, and I think my sister would like it, too. Thanks for reviewing!

pattinase (abbott) said...

I am one of the ones on a long list. This makes me more anxious than ever. I may have to buy it.

troutbirder said...

Unusual and interesting story. Also very relevant both past and present

Powell River Books said...

A timely read. I grew up in Compton, California. Racism was always evident and it boiled up into several riots over the years. And still it continues. - Margy

Phyllis Wheeler said...

This sounds like a timely book. I'll plan to read it. Thanks for the recommendation!

Sarah Laurence said...

It does sound like a topical book for these challenging times. Thanks for reviewing it!